Activists and Pols: We Can’t Wait Another Year to Fix Deadly Third Avenue

Last year, candles burned for each of the five people killed this year in Sunset Park. File photo: Julianne Cuba
Last year, candles burned for each of the five people killed this year in Sunset Park. File photo: Julianne Cuba
It's our December donation drive. Your gift helps us do these kinds of important stories. So please click the logo above.
It’s our December donation drive. Your gift helps us cover important stories, even on Sunday. So please click the logo above.

It was “Death on Third Avenue,” the sequel that no one wanted.

On Sunday, more than a dozen people gathered at 39th Street, just a few blocks and a few months from the last time mourners convened on Third Avenue to protest the horrific death toll on the roadway — where four people in all have been killed by drivers this year alone.

In July, activists rallied to demand changes after the death of cyclist Em Samolewicz, itself an outpouring of grief that followed the death of 26-year-old Hugo Garcia near 28th Street and Fernando Trejo, 27, near 52nd Street, both in January.

“The only thing I can think of today, honestly, is how much it’s not enough what we’re doing,” said Council Member Carlos Menchaca. “We have to ask ourselves what is it going to take — that goal is very much outlined in something the city calls Vision Zero, but we have yet to reach zero.”

The vigil itself was held near the site of the latest death, last week when a truck driver killed 85-year-old Brendan Gill near 39th Street. Gill was one of six pedestrians were killed in both Manhattan and Brooklyn in a 48-hour span last week — including another death in Sunset Park, that of pedestrian Xue You, killed as she tried to cross 52nd Street near Eighth Avenue.

From Garcia to Gill, the Department of Transportation has made only piecemeal changes to the notorious speedway, such as repainting lines.

“That wasn’t enough,” Menchaca said, standing next to his colleague, Council Member Brad Lander.

Council Member Carlos Menchaca and Council Member Brad Lander attend the candlelit vigil. Photo: Julianne Cuba
Council Member Carlos Menchaca and Council Member Brad Lander attend the candlelit vigil. Photo: Julianne Cuba

As mourners lit candles for the victims, a police officer stood on the opposite side of the street checking for speedsters. He declined to say how many truck drivers he has ticketed or what actions he’s taken. The stepped-up enforcement against truck drivers, which Mayor de Blasio announced on Friday, is helpful, but it’s merely a Band-Aid over the gaping wound that is the perilous Third Avenue, said Sunset Parker Jorge Muniz.

“Police have an important role, but what’s needed to fix Third Avenue is not more police. What we need to fix Third Avenue is money, it’s funding,” he said.

A police officer checks for speeding drivers on Third Avenue. Photo: Julianne Cuba

Funding has been allocated, but remains unspent. Rep. Nydia Velazquez said in July then that she got Congress to pay for a protected bike lane and greenway along Third Avenue in 2005. But more than a decade later, it has not been undertaken.

Community Board 7 Chairman Cesar Zuñiga echoed Velazquez’s comments on Sunday, charging that Mayor de Blasio cannot wait for yet another vigil to finally make significant changes to the dangerous roadway. In addition to the five deaths since the start of the year, there’s also been 510 total crashes, resulting in 181 injuries, including 10 cyclists and 13 pedestrians, on Third Avenue between 20th Street and 58th Street, according to Crash Mapper. That’s more than one crash per day on a very short stretch of roadway.

“A few months ago, I asked a question about how many more people have to die before we take action. And here we are again, and I’m asking the same question — how many people more people have to die before we actually take this highway that we have on Third Avenue and make it into a safe space?” said Zuñiga.

And the need to calm the dangerous speedway, which is often used as a shortcut by drivers avoiding the gridlocked Gowanus Expressway above it, is even more urgent now as private developers are expected to build the country’s largest last-mile truck distribution center in the neighborhood in 2020.

“We cannot have these conversations about development without having very serious conversations about how do we slow traffic down and how do we create more pedestrian amenities for safety,” said Zuñiga,


Lentol: Safety Improvements Coming to Meeker Avenue in 2016

DOT will present safety improvements next month for Meeker Avenue by the BQE in Williamsburg, according to Assembly Member Joe Lentol. The department told Lentol’s office it would bring a proposal to Brooklyn Community Board 1 on January 12. Meeker Avenue runs under the BQE for a mile between North 6th Street and Vandevoort Avenue, dividing […]

Tomorrow: Protest Rally in Response to Atlantic Avenue Carnage

The Atlantic Avenue Betterment Association is holding a rally tomorrow in response to two horrific car killings in Boerum Hill in recent weeks. AABA has been fighting for years for more neighborhood-friendly traffic policies along the Avenue. Here are the details: Wednesday, October 25 at 10:00 am on the corner of Atlantic Avenue and Bond […]

Envisioning a Safer Fourth Avenue in Park Slope

Last night, DOT staff led a public workshop sponsored by Borough President Marty Markowitz’s Fourth Avenue Task Force on how to improve 28 blocks of Fourth Avenue in Park Slope, between 15th Street and Pacific Street. DOT expects to have a draft plan for the avenue, one of the borough’s most dangerous streets, within two months. This project follows DOT’s […]

Endless Summer on Brooklyn’s Fifth Avenue

For most New Yorkers the official end of summer is Labor Day which, this year, fell on Monday, September 4, 2006. For astronomers, pagans and Daniel Libeskind’s "Wedge of Light," the end of summer is the Autumnal Equinox, the moment when the sun crosses the celestial equator from north to south. By that measure, Fall begins […]