De Blasio’s Ignorance of NYC’s Bus Crisis Shines Through at His Umpteenth Ferry Announcement

The mayor doesn't seem to know or care how he can reverse the dramatic decline of NYC bus service.

This baby can fit so many subsidies on it! Mayor de Blasio inaugurates the boondoggle NYC Ferry. Photo: Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office
This baby can fit so many subsidies on it! Mayor de Blasio inaugurates the boondoggle NYC Ferry. Photo: Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office

Ask Mayor de Blasio what he’s doing to address the city’s transportation challenges, and he’s likely to focus on one initiative in particular: the city-subsidized ferry service launched at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars, which carried fewer than 10,000 trips per day in 2017.

The city’s bus system, meanwhile, carries about 2 million weekday trips but is hemorrhaging riders, and de Blasio has little to say about it.

Today de Blasio announced that he’s pouring more money into ferries, with another $300 million in capital spending on top of the $325 million his administration has already put into the system. The city also spends $30 million annually on ferry operations.

De Blasio’s press conference, at the just-opened Bay Ridge docks, was at least the eighth ferry-related public event he’s held since the beginning of 2017, compared to two such events for buses.

It’s not like the mayor has no control over bus service. As TransitCenter’s Tabitha Decker laid out in a recent Times opinion piece, it’s up to de Blasio to give buses priority at traffic lights, add more bus lanes, and keep cops from obstructing the bus lanes we already have.

Asked why the city has put hundreds of millions of dollars into the ferry system instead of bus service or Citi Bike, which get much more use, de Blasio said “each element of our mass transit planning has to be seen individually.” In contrast to buses and bike-share, de Blasio bizarrely claimed, ferry service “has tremendous long-term possibility.”

“Adding transportation options for millions of New Yorkers is a good thing,” the mayor said.

De Blasio is misinterpreting the numbers. If annual ferry trips are in the millions, that doesn’t translate to millions of New Yorkers. According to the city’s projection, by 2023 the ferry system will still have just 24,500 passengers per day, fewer than 14 individual MTA bus routes.

Many of those buses are in dire need of improvements that de Blasio could deliver, as TransitCenter noted on Twitter:

You could say there’s “tremendous long-term possibility” in speeding up bus service for hundreds of thousands of people, but the mayor of New York, where more people ride the bus than any other city in the nation, doesn’t see it that way. Maybe that’s because while ferries move fewer people than buses, unlike bus lanes, they don’t irritate motorists by claiming space from car traffic and parking.

It’s been 10 days since the MTA released its “bus action plan,” which has the potential to dramatically improve bus service citywide. For that to happen, de Blasio’s cooperation will be essential. Has the mayor given a moment’s thought to how he can prioritize buses on the streets?

“My broad understanding of the plan — I agree with it and we want to see more and better bus options,” he said.

Seemingly oblivious to the details of the action plan, which calls for applying measures citywide that have previously been rolled out one route at a time as part of the Select Bus Service program, de Blasio highlighted the city’s plan to add two SBS routes per year.

For the $600 million the city is spending on ferry capital needs, plus the $30 million annually in operations, the city could easily increase its expansion of bus lanes by a factor of five for a decade.

Asked whether the NYPD would effectively enforce bus lanes, de Blasio responded that “NYPD success rates at bus lane clearance is not one of the areas I’m an expert in” and declined to comment further.

From 2016 to 2017, citywide bus ridership dropped 6 percent — the highest year-over-year drop in 15 years — as bus speeds continued to fall. Millions of New Yorkers truly are affected by the abysmal state of bus service, but the mayor doesn’t seem to know or care how he can reverse this dramatic decline.


Toll reform creates a fairer transportation system. Ferry subsidies do not. Photo: Michael Appelton/Mayoral Photography Office

De Blasio Launches $325 Million Ferry Service While Poor New Yorkers Struggle to Afford MetroCards

Yesterday the mayor emphasized that the prices for single ferry rides and monthly passes are equivalent to those of single-ride and monthly MetroCards. But ferry riders hoping to connect to other points in the city will have to pay twice - for the boat ride, and again for the subway or bus. And most stops are in neighborhoods where the annual income is above the citywide average.

Bus Rapid Transit, Not Ferry Subsidies, Would Help Struggling New Yorkers

In today’s State of the City address, Mayor de Blasio returned to his signature campaign issues of affordability and equity. Focusing mainly on housing, the mayor outlined a plan for growth centered around transit-accessible neighborhoods, and he recommitted to building several new Bus Rapid Transit routes. But de Blasio missed the mark with his big new transit initiative […]

De Blasio Sounds Prepared to Let the L Train Crisis Go to Waste

The impending L Train shutdown should be a blessing in disguise — the impact of losing service west of Bedford Avenue for 18 months is so great, there’s no good option that doesn’t involve carving out lots of street space for buses, biking, and safer walking. Major redesigns of 14th Street, the Williamsburg Bridge, and the streets connecting to […]