Help Fix the Sanitation Department’s Process for Clearing Abandoned Bikes

Rusty bikes missing wheels, saddles, and other parts are a common sight on NYC sidewalks. Clearly abandoned, they clog up bike racks and other places to lock up, making it harder to park bicycles that people are actively using, and they’re an eyesore to everyone else.

Cleaning up abandoned bikes is the Department of Sanitation’s job, but DSNY’s system isn’t effective, so the problem persists. If you want to make the case that DSNY should change how it handles abandoned bikes, Recycle-A-Bicycle wants your help documenting the performance of the current system.

This abandoned bike on Nostrand does not meet the city's current criteria for removal. Photo: David Meyer
This abandoned bike on Nostrand does not meet the city’s current criteria for removal. Photo: David Meyer

DSNY is holding a hearing on its abandoned bike policy August 9. Before the hearing, Recycle-A-Bicycle is asking New Yorkers to report derelict bikes to 311 and record how the city handles the request.

Under current practice, DSNY responds to 311 complaints about abandoned bicycles by placing a neon tag on the bike, after which owners have one week to remove the tag, or else the bike will be impounded.

But in practice, said Recycle-A-Bicycle Executive Director Karen Overton, “It’s hard to know, if someone calls in a bike, if they [DSNY] actually come out and tag it or don’t.”

So Recycle-A-Bicycle wants to crowdsource an evaluation of DSNY’s system. If you call in an abandoned bike to 311, return in a week to see if the neon tag has been applied, and if so, come back one week later to see if the tag has been cut or the bike has been removed. Each time you check on the bike, you should snap a photo and send it to

DSNY has had the authority to remove derelict bikes since 2010 but hasn’t made much of a visible impact on the problem. “The Department of Sanitation is not set up to fully handle the abandoned bike process, or rescuing abandoned bikes,” Overton said.

Currently DSNY only responds to complaints — it doesn’t actively look to clear bikes that are obviously abandoned. Even if someone does report a bike to 311, DSNY will only remove it if it meets three of the following criteria:

  • It is “crushed or not usable”
  • It’s missing parts
  • It has a flat of missing tires
  • It has damaged handlebars or pedals, and is at least 75 percent rusted

At the meeting on August 9, DSNY will consider three proposed changes: reducing the number of criteria required for removal to two, removing flat or missing tires from the list, and lowering the rust threshold to 50 percent [PDF].

Overton would like to see a major shift in the city’s approach, like the city-wide implementation of a program along the lines of a Recycle-A-Bicycle proposal to provide low-income youth with summer jobs identifying, claiming, and fixing up abandoned bikes to make them useful again.

After a City Council hearing in December on abandoned bikes, DSNY committed to addressing concerns about its bicycle collection process. You can email comments to or testify at the August 9 meeting, which is happening at 10 a.m. in Room 819 or 125 Worth Street.


DSNY Needs to Devise a Better Fix for NYC’s Abandoned Bike Problem

Unusable, forgotten bikes are mainstays of the NYC streetscape, hogging bike parking for months and even years before they meet the Department of Sanitation’s standards for removal. DSNY has proposed a rule change to loosen its criteria, but advocates say it doesn’t go far enough to solve the city’s abandoned bike problem. Reports of abandoned bikes have increased 43 percent this year compared to 2015, […]

How Can DSNY Fix Its Process for Removing Abandoned Bikes?

The city’s process for removing abandoned bikes from public property is broken, advocates say, but a bill proposed by Council Member Brad Lander to deal with the problem needs some adjustments in order to be effective. Abandoned bikes on the sidewalk are an eyesore and make it harder for people using their bikes to find an open spot […]

Sanitation Department Spares Ghost Bikes From Trash Heap

The Department of Sanitation has backed off its controversial plan to remove ghost bikes from the streets of New York, relenting to a public outcry in favor of the memorials to cyclists killed while riding. Proposed rules governing the removal of derelict bicycles released in June would have taken away even the best-maintained memorials, but […]

NYPD Raid Nets Bikes and Bystanders

This entry on the Village Voice Blog by Laura Conaway tells the story of an NYPD raid on parked bicycles last Wednesday night. When two residents questioned the officer in charge, they were arrested: Sparks from the NYPD’s circular saws arced through the night. Police, some in plainclothes, were piling cycles by the dozen in […]