DOT Details Prince Street “Open Sundays” Project


On weekends, 200 vehicles and 4,500 pedestrians per hour make their way down Prince Street, yet
the vast majority of the street’s public space is given over to motor vehicle traffic and parking.

Community Board 2’s Traffic & Transportation Committee heard specifics last night on a DOT pilot project that would open a segment of Prince Street to pedestrians 14 days a year. And as expected, the committee and DOT heard from residents who want the pedestrian-heavy thoroughfare to continue to accommodate cars 24/7/365.

The city proposes to close Prince to cars from Lafayette to W. Broadway on Sundays from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. The project would last from Memorial Day weekend to Labor Day weekend.

According to surveys cited by DOT:

  • Eighty-five percent of people travel to Prince Street by subway, on foot, by bike or on a bus.
  • Eighty percent of pedestrians interviewed on a Saturday "experience the street as being crowded."
  • Expanding pedestrian space would attract people to come to Prince Street more often, where they would spend "about five times as much money" in neighborhood shops and restaurants.
  • On a typical weekend, 200 vehicles travel Prince Street in an hour, compared to 4,500 pedestrians.

While some members of the public spoke in favor, they were easily outnumbered by opponents. "There was a lot of screaming about an out of control street vendor problem that the City seems unwilling or unable to address," one Community Board member said.

For an idea of the tenor of the debate, one supporter of the plan who pointed out that pedestrian streets work in London and other cities was rebutted with cries of "This is New York City!"


…And this is Paris. Does this look like a horrible street to live on?

A key complaint of opponents is that the city doesn’t do enough to enforce rules against sidewalk vending, prompting fears that Prince Street "Open Sundays" would become, in essence, noisy street fairs crowded with kiosks. But one attendee picked up on another strain of contention:

It was clear from last night’s meeting that many of the people against the car-free Prince proposal want fewer pedestrians in the neighborhood, not more. In a sense, they concede that a car-free Prince would be more appealing to outsiders. It’s just not what they want.

Still, the committee ultimately adopted a resolution that, according to committee member Ian Dutton, acknowledges the merits of DOT’s plan but says it is unacceptable because it was
proposed and developed without enough community input. While we have yet to see the actual wording, Dutton says the resolution proposes "forming a
neighborhood stakeholders group to come up with a more comprehensive plan that the community can accept."

The resolution leaves open the possibility that the project is still alive, perhaps with community activists like Sean Sweeney of the SoHo Alliance — currently, a vocal opponent — working with the city to make it more palatable to all.

Graphics: NYC DOT

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Could “Open Sundays” Help Solve Prince Problems?

|
| View | Upload your own Here is the slide show outlining the DOT proposal to open Prince Street to pedestrians on summer Sundays. As we reported yesterday, the plan isn’t popular with some SoHo residents, who say it will turn Prince into another Mulberry Street. But Community Board 2’s Ian Dutton, a supporter of […]

Mime Threat Overshadows Car-Free Prince Street Proposal

|
If you read the comments on the previous post, then you know something interesting is in the works for Prince Street. Next Tuesday, Community Board 2’s Transportation Committee will consider a proposal to turn a six-block stretch of Prince Street, from Lafayette to West Broadway, into a car-free zone on Sundays from 11am to 6pm. […]

CB2 Committee Approves “Additional” Prince/Bleecker Routes

|
The CB2 Traffic & Transportation Committee met at the LGBT Center on Tuesday.  A crowded and often contentious Tuesday night meeting yielded a compromise on proposed bike lanes through Lower Manhattan, one some fear could come at a cost. The Traffic & Transportation Committee of Community Board 2 voted 8-1 to recommend the DOT add […]

CB2 Signs Off On Prince-Bleecker Bike Lanes

|
  After over an hour of public comment, and another hour of deliberation, Community Board 2 last night voted to recommend the DOT proceed with bike lanes parallel to Houston Street, to be located primarily on Prince and Bleecker. The resolution crafted last week by CB2’s Traffic & Transportation Committee — defining the new bike […]

DOT Plans Safety Upgrades at Foot of Manhattan Bridge in Chinatown

|
Choked with car and truck traffic, the Manhattan Bridge ramps around Canal Street are a danger zone. DOT has a plan to tame some of the chaotic crossings for people on foot, which the Manhattan Community Board 3 transportation committee voted in favor of last night. Seven pedestrians and nine motor vehicle occupants were seriously injured at the intersection […]