First Impressions of Mayor Bloomberg’s PlaNYC Testimony…

Did you watch Mayor Bloomberg’s congestion pricing testimony before the New York State legislature? If so, what did you think? Here is the initial impression of John Kaehny, former executive director of Transportation Alternatives: 

Mayor Bloomberg’s advocacy for congestion pricing and public transit to a State assembly panel was the most amazing thing I have seen in 17 years of following New York City transportation reform.

For two hours the mayor, in his new role as transportation policy reformer and environmentalist, engaged with a group of Assembly members who voiced just about every myth, bias and misconception that Livable Streets advocates encounter on a daily basis. The mayor was effective and clearly understands the importance of improving public transit and getting people out of their cars. More than that, the mayor seems to have undergone a revolution in his thinking about transportation. As a result, the gap between Bloomberg’s point of view and the deeply ingrained "windshield perspective" of his questioners was palpable. By the end it seemed that the Mayor’s temper began to fray under the barrage of illogic and distorted questioning.

While Bloomberg deftly addressed most points, questions around issues of fairness and equity could have been handled better. One Assembly member, for example, asked why it is fair to charge a mom to drive her kids from the Upper West to Upper East Side. Bloomberg’s response was not forceful.

The mayor could have answered with a question in return: How is it fair that she should be able to drive for free but would have to pay to take the bus? Or he could have asked the Assembly members what is so fair about low income subway and bus riders having to pay for their city-friendly, non-polluting trips while congestion- and pollution-generating motorists cross city bridges and drive on city streets for free.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Mayor Speaks at Times Square Pricing Rally

|
Supporters of congestion pricing rallied yesterday in Times Square, urging state lawmakers to act by July 16 on Mayor Bloomberg’s initiative or risk losing $500 million in federal funds. "The time is now," said the mayor, according to the New York Post. "We cannot walk away from this opportunity."  Shouting out to tourists in a […]

StreetFilm: Talking Transportation with Bob Kiley

|
Talking Transportation with Bob KileyProduced by Cicala FilmworksRunning Time: 13 minutes 7 seconds The debate over congestion pricing has been heating up in advance of Mayor Bloomberg’s big Earth Day speech tomorrow. What better time to get some talking points on the matter from Bob Kiley, who served as the Commissioner of Transport for London […]

Media (Mostly) Give PlaNYC Its Due

|
When Malcom Murray-Clark, Director of Congestion Charging at Transport for London, visited New York last month, he cited negative media coverage as a major obstacle to implementing the congestion charge in the English capital. By contrast, unlike some, New York media on balance appear willing to give PlaNYC, and congestion pricing, the benefit of the […]

Congestion Pricing: Bloomberg Needs to Sweeten the Deal

|
Webster Avenue and Fordham Road, the Bronx Congestion pricing is in trouble. With just weeks to go before the Traffic Mitigation Commission makes its recommendations to the City Council and State Legislature, public support is waning and opponents appear to have the upper hand. The one sales pitch that scored high in public opinion polls, […]

Après Congestion Pricing, It’s Time to Look at the Paris Model

|
Amsterdam Ave. and 76th St. with street space reallocated to walkers, bikes and buses. When Transportation Alternatives, Project for Public Spaces and the Open Planning Project started the New York City Streets Renaissance Campaign nearly three years ago, the plan was to build a movement that would work block-by-block and neighborhood-by-neighborhood to reclaim the city’s […]