YES IN OUR BACKYARD: New Yorkers Widely Support Parking Reform, Density Near Transit 

This is the opposite of livable streets. Photo: LIRR
This is the opposite of livable streets. Photo: LIRR

New York City voters overwhelmingly support eliminating archaic rules that force developers to build parking that ruins cities, while also supporting dense, transit-oriented development by an even wider margin, according to a new poll released on Wednesday.

The survey, conducted by Slingshot Strategies for Open New York and Regional Plan Association’s New York Neighbors Coalition, found that 68 percent of New Yorkers want to do away with minimum parking requirements as part of new housing developments — a mandate that leads to more congestion, more pollution, less affordable housing and higher construction costs that are passed along to tenants, experts and advocates say.

The poll also showed that 83 percent of voters in the city support building denser development within half a mile of a subway station or any commuter rail station in the MTA coverage area of Long Island and the northern suburbs.

Nixing the parking requirements — in combination with encouraging building more density near transit — are no-brainers in order to reduce driving and rents, according Andrew Fine, the policy director of Open New York.

“What New Yorkers want is lower rents and less congestion. That’s what encouraging transit-oriented development does,” said Fine. “It’s the same reason why widening highways encourages more driving. If you make it easier to be a car owner, whether it’s prioritizing more space for driving, or more space for parking, that encourages people to have more cars.”

According to the poll, only 17 percent of those surveyed oppose eliminating parking requirements, while just 4 percent said they opposed dense transit-oriented development. New York City voters make up 35 percent of the 400 people surveyed statewide for the poll, which has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percent.

The survey comes amid a push by advocates and some pols to end parking requirements. State Sen. Brad Holyman-Sigal (D-Manhattan) introduced legislation last year that would entirely eliminate off-street parking requirements in an attempt to encourage public transit and reduce car ownership. The bill is stuck in committee.

The Open New York findings mirror what Open Plans heard when it polls New Yorkers two years ago. Graphic: Data for Progress
The Open New York findings mirror what Open Plans heard when it polls New Yorkers two years ago. Graphic: Data for Progress

Over time, city officials have reduced mandatory parking minimums to reflect the imperatives of their era. In response to the 1970 Clean Air Act, mandatory parking rules were waived in Manhattan below 96th Street on the East Side and below 110th Street on the West Side; in 2016 as part of a push to develop inner ring neighborhoods, the rules were relaxed in Downtown Brooklyn and parts of Long Island City. The city’s Zoning for Quality and Affordability plan also eliminated parking minimums for fully affordable housing developments in transit-rich areas.

How Streetsblog covered the “City of Yes.” Click to read.

And in a 2018 neighborhood-wide rezoning in Inwood, the city also reduced parking minimums for all new developments.

In her 2022 State of the State, Gov. Hochul unveiled a plan to encourage density by giving the city the power increase floor-area ratio — a measurement of how large a building can be relative its lot size — in residential buildings. She didn’t touch on eliminating parking minimum, but did call for more transit-oriented development — and the two are connected, Hoylman said at the time.

Similarly, under Mayor Adams’s “City of Yes” zoning proposal, the Department of City Planning started a lengthy review process in support of three initiatives, one of which is a provision to “prioritize people over parking to make streets safer, and reduce requirements to enable more of the housing, services, and amenities that help neighborhoods thrive.”

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

City Council’s Zeal for Affordable Housing Crumbles If It Means Less Parking

|
On Tuesday, members of the City Council hammered the de Blasio administration for not guaranteeing enough housing units for low-income New Yorkers in new construction. But yesterday, when the topic turned to building more affordable housing by reducing parking requirements, several Council members lost their zeal for housing and worried more about car storage. The hearing yesterday […]

DCP Releases Timid Parking Reform Study for the Boroughs

|
A report from the Department of City Planning issued during the final days of the Bloomberg administration is a trove of data about parking, but a look behind the pretty maps reveals a department that remains focused on dictating the supply of parking spaces and reluctant to use its power to reduce traffic and improve housing […]

4 More City Council Members Weigh in on Parking Reform

|
Last week, City Hall’s proposal to reduce parking minimums for subsidized housing near transit got a hearing in the City Council, and for the most part it wasn’t pretty. Council members may say they want more affordable housing, but for many of them, that support gets shaky if it means requiring less parking in residential development. The parking reforms are part […]

Queens Community Board Chairs Care About Parking More Than Housing

|
Give it up for Queens community board chairs. Thanks to a vote last night, we now have a crystal clear expression of their priorities. Nothing is more important than parking. In a city without enough housing to go around, where rising rents are squeezing people in more neighborhoods every year, the community board chairs have taken a bold […]