DOT: The Barnes Dance Isn’t Usually the Best Tool to Make Intersections Safer

A DOT report recommends leading pedestrian intervals, split-phase signals, and physical improvements as other tools to protect people on foot from turning drivers.

All-pedestrian signals can delay buses and make sidewalk crowding worse at typical high-volume intersections like Seventh Avenue and 34th Street, according to DOT. Image: DOT
All-pedestrian signals can delay buses and make sidewalk crowding worse at typical high-volume intersections like Seventh Avenue and 34th Street, according to DOT. Image: DOT

DOT has released a report on the pros and cons of all-pedestrian signal phases — popularly known as Barnes Dance crossings — at city intersections. While Barnes Dance treatments can improve safety for people crossing the street, DOT prefers other safety treatments in most circumstances.

The report [PDF], which was prompted by the City Council, says all-way pedestrian signals work well in very specific conditions, including intersections with unusual layouts, crossings with diagonal desire paths, and intersections that are near transit hubs.

Depending on traffic patterns, Barnes Dances can delay buses and people on bikes, according to DOT, with cascading effects on nearby intersections. Longer pedestrian wait times can cause sidewalk crowding and lead to non-compliance with traffic signals, the report says, countering the benefit of reducing pedestrian-motorist conflicts.

The report cites a 2015 study of five Manhattan intersections, all near transit hubs and with high volumes of pedestrian traffic, which were candidates for all-pedestrian signals. At Seventh Avenue and W. 34th Street outside Penn Station, for example, DOT found that a Barnes Dance with a diagonal crossing would increase average wait times for all street users.

The report recommends leading pedestrian intervals, split-phase signals, and physical improvements like sidewalk extensions and pedestrian islands as other tools to protect people on foot from turning drivers.

There are currently 86 NYC intersections with all-pedestrian phases, according to DOT. The report says DOT will consider adding Barnes Dances at intersections with atypical geometry, intersections where most or all drivers make turns, T intersections, and intersections with low volumes of motorized traffic.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Tonight: Support Major Ped and Bike Improvements at CB3 Meeting

|
Pedestrian plazas would reclaim six intersections connecting the Allen and Pike Street malls. Apologies for the last-minute heads up, but livable streets supporters in Chinatown and the Lower East Side won’t want to miss this action at Community Board 3 tonight. A DOT project to expand pedestrian space and add center median protected bike paths […]

Brooklyn’s Fort Greene Fights for Livable Streets

|
DOT’s failure to provide a traffic signal or even a simple crosswalk at intersections along DeKalb Avenue disconnects the neighborhood from its bus stops and its park. Brooklyn’s Fort Greene Association is running an exemplary grassroots campaign on local pedestrian safety issues. The neighborhood group has generated more than 500 letters to DOT requesting specific improvements in crosswalk layouts […]