Instead of a Classon Avenue Bike Lane, Bed-Stuy Electeds Want a Street Where No One Rides Bikes

City Council Member Robert Cornegy, State Senator Velmanette Montgomery, and Assembly Member Tremaine Wright say that adding some stripes and stencils goes too far. Borough President Eric Adams, meanwhile, says the project should proceed.

Lauren Davis was killed by a turning driver on Classon Avenue last April. Photo: Family of Lauren Davis
Lauren Davis was killed by a turning driver on Classon Avenue last April. Photo: Family of Lauren Davis

On Thursday, DOT announced plans to paint a bike lane on Classon Avenue, the northbound one-way street where a left-turning driver killed Lauren Davis as she rode her bike to work last April. As bicycle infrastructure goes, it’s the bare minimum — some stripes and stencils to designate space for biking, with no changes to moving lanes or parking. But that hasn’t stopped a group of local officials from coming out against it.

The project is set for installation this summer, DOT Brooklyn Borough Commissioner Keith Bray said in a April 11 letter obtained by DNAinfo [PDF]. On most blocks, a new stripe of thermoplast will divide what is now a 13-foot parking lane into a five-foot bike lane and eight-foot parking lane. Blocks that have two travel lanes will only get sharrows:

Image: DOT
Image: DOT

Nearly 6,000 people signed a petition from Davis’s family asking for a bike lane on Classon Avenue. Now that DOT is moving forward with the new stripes, three elected officials are trying to block it.

In a June 12 letter rife with errors and misinformation, Council Member Robert Cornegy, State Senator Velmanette Montgomery, Assembly Member Tremaine Wright, and CB 3 chair Richard Flateau informed DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg of their “significant opposition” to the project.

It’s hard to find a single factual statement in the entire letter, which begins with the assumption that “the decision to convert the existing lane into a conventional bike lane on the west side of the street will not increase safety but will in fact cause additional fatalities.” They go on to argue that the painted lane will “slow down cars,” “impede… timely delivery of goods and services,” and result in “a deleterious impact on economic development.” Of course, no real world examples of the link between bike stencils and economic decline are cited.

Apparently, nothing less than a bicycle-free street will satisfy the signatories. Since Bedford Avenue, Franklin Avenue, Marcy Avenue, and Tompkins Avenue have bike lanes, they argue that the area has a shortage of north-south routes where commercial vehicle drivers can “avoid cyclists.”

“As elected officials who are charged with supporting the needs of all constituents (bicyclists and motorists),” they continue, “we cannot and will not support one group over another.” At least there’s an inadvertent truth buried in there — opposing these basic safety improvement benefits nobody.

“We understand and sympathize with the on-going loss the Davis family is experiencing,” they conclude. “However, DOT needs to think of other ways to keep bikers safety other than instituting a quick fix.” As for what those “other ways” might be, don’t bother looking for specific, usable ideas from this letter.

The Classon Avenue bike lane does have the backing of Borough President Eric Adams, who declared his support for the project last week.

Meanwhile, Lauren Davis’s family continues to seek some measure of accountability for the driver who struck and killed her.

The initial NYPD crash report incorrectly claimed Davis was riding against the direction of traffic, effectively blaming her for her own death. The report was eventually amended to reflect the culpability of the driver, Jennine Chung. But a judge at Chung’s initial DMV safety hearing only had the incorrect, victim-blaming police account. The NYPD officer assigned to the case failed to show up to correct the record.

He came to the follow-up hearing last week, but the DMV judge adjourned the proceedings because Chung’s lawyer was not present, scheduling the next hearing for May 2018, according to Lauren’s sister, Danielle. It could be years before Chung faces any repercussions for killing Lauren Davis, which could take the form of either a license suspension or revocation.

“I am very disappointed and frustrated,” said Danielle Davis. “It feels like invisibility is the only form of representation Lauren deserves in the eyes of the judicial system.”


The intersection of Classon and Lexington, where Lauren Davis was struck and killed by a turning driver last April.

Family of Lauren Davis Asks CB 3 to Support Classon Ave Bike Lane

Davis was biking on Classon in the direction of traffic on the morning of April 15 when a left-turning driver in a Fiat struck and killed her. Her sister Danielle launched an online petition urging community boards 2 and 3 and local council members Laurie Cumbo and Robert Cornegy, Jr. to support a bike lane on Classon, and almost 6,000 people have signed on.

Bowing to Brooklyn CB 3, DOT Puts Bed Stuy Slow Zone on Ice

Bedford Stuyvesant won’t be getting 20 mph streets after all. Despite months of talks after Brooklyn Community Board 3 rejected a request from neighborhood residents for a 20 mph Slow Zone in February, DOT has decided to pull the plug on a traffic calming plan covering 23 blocks of Bed Stuy, effectively giving the community board […]

DOT Planning Buffered Bike Lane on Lafayette Avenue in Fort Greene

DOT plans to install a buffered bike lane this summer on Lafayette Avenue in Brooklyn between Fulton Street and Classon Avenue. The project, which the Brooklyn Community Board 2 transportation committee voted for unanimously last night, calls for a five-foot bike lane protected by a three-foot buffer zone [PDF]. It will be an upgrade from the current shared lane […]

DOT’s Fear of Community Boards Leads to Bike Lane Gaps in Brooklyn

Disjointed street design changes coming to Kingston Avenue and Brooklyn Avenue illustrate how DOT’s sheepish approach to bike lane implementation interferes with the development of a connected bike network. At Fulton Street in Bed-Stuy, these north-south routes connect with Tompkins Avenue and Throop Avenue, which both have bike lanes. But for years, the bike lanes didn’t extend south […]