Why Won’t the “New York Works Fund” Pay for Transit?

Andrew Cuomo's big infrastructure push, the New York Works Fund, won't include transit projects. Why? ##http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cuomo_2010_cropped.jpg##Photo via Wikimedia.##

Despite the fact that over one quarter of the state’s population takes transit to work, Governor Andrew Cuomo’s marquee infrastructure program won’t invest in public transportation. With so much still unknown about the governor’s “New York Works Fund” — including very basic information about how it will be structured — the reason why Cuomo is excluding transit remains elusive.

State DOT Commissioner Joan McDonald confirmed that transit won’t be included in the fund at a legislative hearing two weeks ago. According to the Tri-State Transportation Campaign, Manhattan State Senator Liz Krueger asked McDonald whether any transit projects would be eligible for the fund. “McDonald answered in the negative,” reported Tri-State’s Nadine Lemmon.

“The senator thinks it would be tragic if the state did not prioritize significant investment in both upstate and downstate mass transportation maintenance, modernization and expansion,” said a spokesperson for Krueger, who confirmed Tri-State’s account.

While the fund won’t include transit, it will provide funding for highways, bridges, municipal water systems, dams, and even state parks and historic sites. In his State of the State address this January, Cuomo said the fund would “master plan, coordinate, leverage, and accelerate capital investment,” and “leverage state investment by a multiple of 20-to-1.”

Exactly what the fund is, however, isn’t at all clear. “There’s no legislation or language,” explained Tammy Gamerman, a senior research associate with the Citizens Budget Commission who’s been following the New York Works Fund. Right now, she explained, the “New York Works Fund” label doesn’t refer to an actual fund so much as a way of conceptually packaging infrastructure spending. “It’s a way of thinking about different infrastructure investments together, rather than as separate.”

The governor’s office has not responded to Streetsblog requests for an explanation of how the New York Works Fund is set up. “The governor hasn’t revealed exactly what will be done or and how much of it was scheduled to be done anyway by repackaging of existing aid to minimize new spending,” reported the Associated Press last month.

The biggest unanswered questions involve Cuomo’s promise to leverage state investment with 20 private dollars for every public dollar. The private sector needs to make a return on its investment, of course, and alternative financing doesn’t eliminate the need to actually fund infrastructure investments. If Cuomo isn’t willing to pay for roadwork with a gas tax increase or tolls, it’s not clear how the private sector would be compensated.

As Elizabeth Lynam, vice president of the Citizens Budget Commission, told the AP: “It’s hard to fit the number together right now and know where all this financing capacity is going to come from. It’s not as though everything out there is free. Somebody is going to have to pay for it somewhere along the line.”

At the same time, Cuomo is also billing the reconstruction of the Tappan Zee Bridge as a New York Works Fund project, although it won’t be receiving any private financing. What defines a New York Works Fund project, in other words, seems flexible at this point.

So if the New York Works Fund is so far just an act of political branding, why is the Cuomo administration proactively declaring transit ineligible for the funds?

It’s possible that the fund will be structured in a way that precludes its use for transit, whether for legal or financial reasons. Gamerman, however, said she hadn’t heard of any such obstacle. “I don’t think there’s any structural reason for it,” she said. “I think they chose to keep transit separate.”

The Cuomo administration has also chosen not to fund the remaining three years of the MTA’s capital program, a far more significant fiscal decision. That left the MTA $9 billion short of what it needs to pay for badly-needed system repairs and the ongoing expansion of the system. Even if the New York Works Fund were to include transit, it’s impossible that the fund as currently imagined could close that enormous gap. The New York Works Fund is of less concern to New York City transit riders than the need for a new revenue stream to pay for the MTA capital program.

Even so, it’s worth keeping an eye on how the New York Works Fund takes shape. Depending on what the fund actually turns into, it has the potential to be one more way the Cuomo administration shortchanges the state’s transit riders.


Cuomo on MTA Raids: Transit Funds Are “Fungible”

WNYC’s Andrea Bernstein reports on the most troubling sign yet that Governor-elect Andrew Cuomo is not willing to stop Albany’s practice of raiding dedicated transit funds to plug gaps in the state budget. From a press conference yesterday: Cuomo: “I understand the concern. Everyone — especially in a declining budget environment, where we are now, […]

Sooner or Later, the Cuomo Fare Hike Is Coming

Earlier this week, Streetsblog contributor Charles Komanoff crunched the numbers to see what could happen if Governor Andrew Cuomo doesn’t follow through on his pledge to restore the $320 million in MTA funding cuts he signed into law on Monday. The cost to commuters, the economy, and public health, he found, could substantially outweigh the […]

Andrew Cuomo’s Transit Plan: Worse Than Nothing?

With November 2 just 11 days away, it’s probably time to concede that Andrew Cuomo won’t offer any constructive ideas for solving the state’s transit funding crisis before election day. After avoiding taking any stands while outlining his infrastructure plan, Cuomo happily joined in the gubernatorial debate’s MTA-bashfest, trotting out the old and discredited “two […]

Among Democrats, Cuomo Lags Far Behind on Transit Policy

When it comes to transit, Andrew Cuomo seems to see only the costs and never the benefits. Responding to near-unanimous support for transit on the Tappan Zee Bridge from the Hudson Valley’s elected officials, including the county executives on both sides of the river, Cuomo spokesperson Matt Wing had this to say last week: If […]

Cuomo: College Should Be Priced Rationally. Roads? Not So Much.

At a press conference today, Governor Cuomo touted a new plan to introduce a “rational” pricing mechanism to help the state provide critical resources to New York residents. He was talking, of course, about SUNY tuition, which will be structured to rise five percent a year for the next five years. As for introducing a […]